Shelsky's of Brooklyn

Tienda de bagels y Marisquería$$$$
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn
  • Los expertos de Serious Eats y Time Out New York recomiendan este lugar
    • Serious Eats
    • Time Out New York
  • Ryan K.
    "All the smoked salmon (salmón ahumado) varieties, fish salads, picked herring"(10 Tips)
    "whitefish (pescado blanco) and Riesling sauerkraut on pumpernickel"(4 Tips)
    Alex R.
    "baked salmon (pescado al horno) salad on a freshly toasted bagel."(3 Tips)
    Luis L.
    "Transplant and spicy (picante) red sandwiches."(11 Tips)
118 Tips y reseñas
  • sándwiches
  • auténtico
  • brunch
  • pastrami
  • hígado
Ingresa para dejar un tip aquí.

  • Recientes
  • Populares
  • Teddy
    Teddyhace 5 días
    The Peter Shelsky has Gaspe Nova, Sable, and Pickled Herring. It's absolutely delicious.
  • Dylan G.
    I get the Great Gatsby, hold the horseradish cream cheese, add their apple horseradish 👌💯
  • Terri R.
    Terri RMarzo 8
    The Peter Shelsky was so delicious! I got it on an everything bagel. Can’t wait to go back and try more things.
  • Zach L.
    Zach LinderFebrero 16
    Ha estado aquí más de 5 veces
    Everything here is excellent, but I particularly love whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, and tomato on pumpernickel. Then some herring with cream and onions on the side.
  • Jesse L.
    Jesse LaneFebrero 4
    I am a Jew, and I approve this message. All about the Brooklyn Transplant.
  • John D.
    John DempseyDiciembre 2, 2017
    This place is special. ❤️ 🐟
  • Luis L.
    Luis LópezOctubre 8, 2017
    Good place. Transplant and spicy red sandwiches.
  • Adam K.
    Adam KirschenbaumJulio 22, 2017
    Ha estado aquí más de 5 veces
    Super cool Jewish deli vibe, and the fish is as good as anywhere. Always just a tiny bit of sticker shock, but always worth it. :)
  • Sommer P.
    Sommer P.Julio 14, 2017
    Paul: "Smoked salmon on a everything bagel"
  • Sandra R.
    Sandra RubinchikJunio 15, 2017
    The only cheeses they have are cream and Swiss.
  • Sam G.
    Sam GilAbril 30, 2017
    Brooklyn Native is so so good, and I'm not even a herring fan. No need to go to Manhattan. Not stupid busy. Great gatsby was very good but the mustard was a little too sweet. Must visit.
  • Lindsey F.
    Lindsey FrancesMarzo 29, 2017
    Holy smoked fish this place is delicious
  • Adrian P.
    Adrian PhillipsMarzo 20, 2017
    People who work here are legends. Sandwiches are not to be missed. Come loaded with fish and other delicious goodness. Highly recommend the Brooklyn Transplant, Member of the Tribe and Great Gatsby.
  • Michelle L.
    Michelle LeedsFebrero 28, 2017
    The bagels are legit, but it's kinda stressful waiting to order
  • Ben K.
    Quality Jewish appetizing shop with everything you need from lox to chopped liver to knishes and hamantashen. Try the Peter Shelsky and Great Gatsby sandwiches.
  • Giovanni B.
    Giovanni Bryden RosasEnero 18, 2017
    Life-changing sandwiches are made here. The eponymous Peter Shelsky sandwich is a must have.
  • AJ M.
    AJ MentaikoEnero 15, 2017
    Get the salmon bacon!
  • Megan M.
    Megan MezaDiciembre 30, 2016
    Chopped liver a little chewy, but awesome sandwiches. Long live the Jewish Deli!
  • Morgan C.
    Morgan CroneyNoviembre 6, 2016
    Great smoked salmon. Lots of pressure to get 1/2 rather than 1/4 lb. of everything. Bagels are not amazing but salmon and whitefish are.
  • Ashley A.
    Ashley AlvarezSeptiembre 22, 2016
    One bagel with the works is enough for two at this little heaven
  • eric m.
    eric mortensenSeptiembre 19, 2016
    Good food, but I'm fairly certain that nobody who works here has ever made the sandwiches listed on the big board. I'm greeted with a blank stare every time I order one.
  • Saba N.
    Saba NekoSeptiembre 12, 2016
    I dream of Shelsky's 😍😍😍 the tribute! Delicious
  • Alex B.
    Alex BosworthAgosto 17, 2016
    This place is next level good, get the gatsby
  • Hannah G.
    Hannah GMAgosto 7, 2016
    Best smoked fish in Brooklyn! The whitefish salad and lox are fantastic - and don't miss the full-sour pickles.
  • Katie S.
    Katie ShieldsJulio 20, 2016
    The great gatsby sandwich
  • Drewski
    DrewskiJulio 9, 2016
    Known for their great fish, but the bagels themselves were mediocre.
  • Andrew W.
    Andrew WeiserJunio 10, 2016
    Get the Tuna Pan Bagnat. It's red leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, Kalamata olives, hard-boiled egg, anchovies, and Spanish tuna. One caveat: Only six are available on Saturdays and Sundays.
  • alex r.
    alex rockMayo 25, 2016
    Ha estado aquí más de 5 veces
    Holy crap, the salmon bacon is the best thing I've eaten in my entire life. Also, great sandwiches.
  • Alissa L.
    Alissa LudanskaaAbril 25, 2016
    Great bagels and toppings! Loved all of it! White fish salad is a star!
  • EM H.
    EM H.Marzo 27, 2016
    The lox on the Member of the Tribe is phenomenal!
  • Betty K.
    Betty KimMarzo 27, 2016
    Ha estado aquí más de 5 veces
    Best Lox ever
  • Megan G.
    Megan GilbrideMarzo 11, 2016
    Great bagels and smoked fish, friendly staff
  • Rudy V.
    Rudy ValentaFebrero 22, 2016
    Good balance of lox and cream cheese
  • Carl M.
    Carl MartinFebrero 20, 2016
    The Great Gatsby just made it's way into my top 3 sandwiches in New York. Holy moly it's delicious.
  • Shah
    ShahEnero 31, 2016
    The Holy Mackerel is heavenly.
  • Jack T.
    Jack TarEnero 29, 2016
    The first time I had no money but had a look around. They kept asking me if I wanted any thing and I told them yes and I had a big plate of variety. I have taken many friends. The bestest.
  • Christoffer J.
    Christoffer JakobsenEnero 15, 2016
    Ha estado aquí más de 5 veces
    Just wow! Amazing smoked salmon bagels.
  • Ryan E.
    Ryan EickEnero 3, 2016
    The bagel and lox is incredible
  • Yelena
    YelenaDiciembre 2, 2015
    I've had better.
  • Micke H.
    Micke HåkanssonNoviembre 7, 2015
    Ha estado aquí más de 10 veces
    Awesome bagels and love the Gravlax. Almost like the Swedish original.
  • Jane C.
    Jane CampbellNoviembre 1, 2015
    Member of the tripe with everything bagel was spectacular- it was simple and silky beauty- good for a first time taster. Yum!!!
  • Gideon O.
    Gideon OlshanskyOctubre 26, 2015
    Ha estado aquí más de 25 veces
    The smoked fish is incredible and they have a great selection
  • Sarah H.
    Sarah HaskinsOctubre 17, 2015
    Smoked salmon
  • Sebastian P.
    Sebastian Perez SaaibiOctubre 4, 2015
    The great gatsby. Don't look further and enjoy!!!
  • Saif D.
    Saif DiaSeptiembre 8, 2015
    The salmon bacon is fantastic
  • Mollie G.
    Mollie GoldsteinAgosto 29, 2015
    The mild Scottish smoked salmon is perfection.
  • Wendy Q.
    Wendy QiuJulio 19, 2015
    Delicious, cleaner, friendlier and less cramped version of Russ and daughters 💯
  • Liam K.
    Liam K.Julio 9, 2015
    Get the Shelsky's sandwich and some pickled things from the cold case. Food like this is a rarity.
  • Keith W.
    Keith WoodJunio 27, 2015
    Don't leave without trying the David Burke pastrami salmon. Put it on a bagel with a horseradish smear and other fixings and you won't be dissapointed!
  • Sabrina M.
    Sabrina MajeedJunio 23, 2015
    Ha estado aquí más de 10 veces
    The Great Gatsby is my go-to. Maple cured salmon + cream cheese and red onions is a great and filling combo.
216 Fotos

Búsquedas similares

  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn
  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn photos
  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn location
  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn address
  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn
  • shelsky brooklyn
  • shelsky's brooklyn
  • shelsky's of brooklyn brooklyn
  • shelsky's smoked fish brooklyn
  • shelskys brooklyn
  • shelskys of brooklyn brooklyn
  • shelskys smoked fish brooklyn
  • shelsky's of brooklyn cobble hill brooklyn

Foursquare © 2018  Lovingly made in NYC, SF & Chicago